Рецензия на книгу

• 

  Аноним12 октября 2025 г.

  The first book that you are actually feeling a significant difference between movie

  First thing that I want to say that after reading this book I've appreciated the movie even more.

  It felt like the book was heavy (not in a bad way) and even darker then a movie yet they've managed the make it so compelling and uniquely authentic.
  Movie made an incredible job to show the time-turner events in a better way from my point. Like this little example when Hermine threw a little rock into the Hargid's hut. For me, it was great to show more examples outside of Harry's patronus.

  Another thing for me was how they've actually made a Harry's appearance at Hogsmeade lovely and sweat unlike in book when it's pretty stressful and dark in some sense which is fine but the feeling after those are completely different.

  The fact that Ron was amazed to see Harry and Hermione literally teleporting at the end of the movie was also so fun for me that I've definitely prefer this one over the book's version. And this play around the "how can somebody be in two places at once" throughout has was fun and this at the end was like a great exclamation point at the end.

  And also Dumbledore pretending that he had no idead what Harry and Hermione had done was a cool little thing.

  But let's focus on a book now

  I generally believe that an entire plot about Percy and Gryffindor in general finally winning a Quidditch Cup is amazing one. It was so amazing to see Fred and George showing the different sides of their characters.
  All the emotions that Wood experienced at the end.
  This iconic game - we should be ahead at least for 50 points
  Everything was amazing

  The entire pre-story of Marauders was such an amazing thing.
  I wasn't expected it to be so reach and long yet I was happy to find out how Lumen become an Animagus.
  How his friends became an Animaguses just for him and had fun together.
  That was such a touching story

  Also an entire plot of Hermione hating Divination and eventually dropping it was pretty damn fun and unexpected.

  Yeah, the Hogsmeade. As I said before this hidden trips by Harry was barely felt enjoyable and fun due to this non-stop threat of Black and general Harry's restrictions.

  Also Crookshanks is my hero. That's all that you need to know.

  Oh yeah.
  I've heard that some of Severus's Snape's sides hasn't been demonstrated in movie.
  And now I can see it. Definitely. When he lost his temper in Shrieking Shack and even insulted Hermione. That's a completely unexpected turn of events.

  Final note that I want to say is that despite all the excluded plots being so amazing the feeling after the Black's saving mission is completely different and slightly off compared to book.
  Maybe in was my expectations after movie, but the Black's saving was less exciting, there was less emotions and feeling between Harry and Sirius but also Sirius and Hermione.

  Also despite it being an amazing thing for Harry it never strikes me that an actually happy ending of the book. It was like yes but there's still a threat which is fair to be honest if you remind yourself that a Wormtail is Voldemort's slave. Yet I've barely felt any joy compared to movies.

  Despite that it's still an unbelievable book.

  Содержит спойлерыОткрыть

  4

  67