Рецензия на книгу

• 

  George312 ноября 2012 г.

  A slow-moving novel whose slight plot seems to be merely a vehicle for Clark to pitch an enormous space-based radio telescope to search for extra-solar life.
  The thing I thought was really clever and wonderful about this book is the two worlds it depicts - Titan, where the atmosphere is made out of methane and ammonia; and Earth, where civilization has advanced to such an astonishing degree that there's no more violence (even Duncan, the rugged colonist, has never handled a weapon, eaten meat, or killed anything), everything is very safe, and Earth's high-technology civilization coexists peacefully with its resurgent wilderness.
  The main thing I didn't like was an odd failure of characterization: the one major female character, Calindy, never seemed quite real to me. Part of this is because most of our first impressions of her come from Duncan's rosy, soft-focus recollections of her from early adolescence, when he and Karl both became infatuated with her, but some of it does come from Clarke's failure to give her a discernible inner life.

  4

  23